Literary Kicks

Opinions, Observations and Research


Favorite Series

Levi Asher's Memoir of the Internet Industry, 1993-2003

Marcel Proust: Beyond The Madeleines

The Great Book Pricing Debate of 2007

Overrated Writers of 2006

FEATURED ARTICLES FROM 2010
• A Murder and a Metaphor: Litkicks Mystery Spot #1
• Five Hiphop Masterpieces From The Past Decade #3: Graduation
• Up In The Air With Walter Kirn
All Articles From 2010

FEATURED ARTICLES FROM 2009
• A Memoir In Progress
• THE LAUNCH
• Marcel Proust: Beyond the Madeleines
All Articles From 2009

FEATURED ARTICLES FROM 2008
• Les Soixante-Huitards
• Jeff VanderMeer, The Hardest Working Man in Fantasy
• The Alzheimer's Poetry Slam
All Articles From 2008

FEATURED ARTICLES FROM 2007
• Cormac McCarthy: Owning My Hate
• Richard Nash, Mark Sarvas, Scott Hoffman on Book Pricing for Literary Fiction
• Five Hot Fictional Characters
All Articles From 2007

FEATURED ARTICLES FROM 2006
• Overrated Writers, Part One: Philip Roth
• Running With The Turcottes: An Interview With Susan Winters Smith
• Overrated Writers, Part Three: William Vollmann
All Articles From 2006

FEATURED ARTICLES FROM 2005
• About Us
• The Mary Shelley Story
• Metafiction and the 4th Wall
All Articles From 2005

FEATURED ARTICLES FROM 2004
• Danger on Peaks: Gary Snyder’s Latest
• No Exit
• Cabaradio! Music, Poetry, Dance, and More in D.C.
All Articles From 2004

FEATURED ARTICLES FROM 2003
• E. E. Cummings
• T.S. Eliot’s The Waste Land
• Gunter Grass and The Tin Drum
All Articles From 2003

FEATURED ARTICLES FROM 2002
• On Western Haiku
• This is Marriage? The Beat Generation and Gregory Corso’s ‘Marriage’
• Ann Beattie
All Articles From 2002

FEATURED ARTICLES FROM 2001
• J. D. Salinger
• Richard Brautigan
• Henry David Thoreau
All Articles From 2001

FEATURED ARTICLES FROM 2000
• Beat News: December 14 2000
• Beat News: September 7 2000
All Articles From 2000

FEATURED ARTICLES FROM 1999
• LitKicks Summer Poetry Happening at the Bitter End
• Beat News: October 8 1999
• Beat News: August 21 1999
All Articles From 1999

FEATURED ARTICLES FROM 1998
• Jack Micheline
• Hymn to the Rebel Cafe
• Beat News: May 5 1998
All Articles From 1998

FEATURED ARTICLES FROM 1997
• How I Met Ginsberg
• Sliced Bardo: Bardo in Kansas
• Sliced Bardo: On Burroughs by Robert Creeley
All Articles From 1997

FEATURED ARTICLES FROM 1996
• d. a. levy
• Ted Joans
• An Evening At Biblio’s
All Articles From 1996

FEATURED ARTICLES FROM 1995
• My Audition for On The Road
• Tangier
• Ringside Seat: Gerald Nicosia vs. Ann Charters at NYU
All Articles From 1995

FEATURED ARTICLES FROM 1994
• Allen Ginsberg
• William S. Burroughs
• Neal Cassady
All Articles From 1994

About LitKicks

Literary Kicks was born on July 23, 1994. Here's a page about who we are and where we've been.

Africa
African-American
American
Arabic
Audio Literature
Awards
Beat Generation
Being A Writer
Big Thinking
Biography
Bookselling
Breakfast Club
British
Classics
Comedy
Comix
Drama
Eastern
Eastern European
Ecology
Economics
Events
Existential
Fantasy
Fiction
Film
French
Haiku
Harlem Renaissance
Hiphop
History
Indie
Internet Culture
Interviews
Jazz Age
Jewish
Kid Lit
La Boheme
Language
Latin
Lists
Lit-Crit
LitKicks
Love
Memes
Modernism
Music
Mystery
National Poetry Month
Nature
New York City
News
Overrated Writers
Personal
Places
Poetry
Poetry Readings
Poker
Politics
Polls and Questions
Postmodernism
Psychology
Publishing
Reading
Religion
Reviews
Romantic
Russian
Science Fiction
Southern
Spoken Word
Sports
Summer Of Love
Technology
Television
The Memoir
Transcendentalism
Transgressive
Tributes
Uncategorized
Victorian
Visual Art
What Are You Reading
Women

Reviewing the Review: September 23 2007

by Levi Asher on Saturday, September 22, 2007 10:38 am
A graphic redesign of the print edition of the New York Times Book Review's launches with this weekend's issue. Designer Nicholas Blechman seems to like white space, a strange wide ribbon of which adorns the top of each page. I don't see what purpose this serves, but I suppose no significant damage is done.

Here's the more exciting change: the NYTBR has just launched a new weekly bestseller list featuring my favorite format (you haven't heard?), trade paperback! Smart, smart, good, good. The first number one title on this debuting list is Sara Gruen's Water For Elephants, and you better believe I'm hoping this new list will help our industry evolve more quickly away from its currently dominant format for fiction, that elephantine object known as the hardcover.

One slight quibble: if the new list is titled "Paperback Best Sellers" (divided into "Trade Fiction", headed by Sara Gruen's elephants, and "Mass Market Fiction", headed by David Baldacci's The Collectors), why is the hardcover list titled "Best Sellers" and not "Hardcover Best Sellers"? If any format deserves the unqualified title "Best Sellers", shouldn't that be the format that sells the most total units of the three? But I'm happy with small changes and I'll back off this point for now.

Structural changes aside, this issue of the Book Review is packed with rewarding stuff. Dale Peck turns in a 40th anniversary appreciation of S. E. Hinton's The Outsiders that softly but gloriously illuminates its subject, which is exactly what all those dumb, repititious 50th anniversary appreciations of Kerouac's On The Road last month didn't do. Peck wonders how a 17-year-old from Oklahoma could write with such broad appeal and concludes that books like The Heart is a Lonely Hunter and films like Rebel Without A Cause and West Side Story deeply informed young S. E. Hinton. But this does not diminish her acheivements at all, especially since she had the intuitive good sense to make her junior-hoodlum narrator a dreamy film freak and book lover. Hinton's lack of originality resonates harmonically with her hero's cramped yearnings, and textual borrowings that a mean-spirited reader might call plagiarism are instead revealed as the best kind of creative alchemy. Peck writes:

I was reminded of 19-year-old Kaavya Viswanathan, who was flayed last year for borrowing excessively from various sources for her own novel. If some high-minded, plagiarism-wary reader had persuaded S. E. Hinton to remove all references to the books and movies that inspired her, "The Outsiders" probably wouldn't have slipped past the internal (let alone official) censors that governed 60's adolescence.

Controversies aside, I mainly like Peck's piece because he treats this young adult classic with generous respect and endeavors to tell us things about the book that we haven't heard before. Which is, again, what all the 50th anniversary blatherings about Kerouac last month didn't do.

This Book Review has more good articles than I have time to write about or (I bet) than you have patience to read about. Katie Roiphe's explication of Janet Malcolm's new Gertrude Stein book Two Lives: Gertrude and Alice helps me understand my own confused but fascinated reaction to Malcolm's intentionally fractured approach to biography (I just finished reading this slim book myself, and hope to write more about it soon). Daniel Handler is wild about Jim Shepard's story collection Like You'd Understand, Anyway. David Bowman tries to explain Brock Clarke's An Arsonists' Guide to Writers' Homes in New England to the many NYTBR readers who will probably find the title frightening.

I wish Paul Berman's lushly self-important article on Vaclav Havel's autobiography To The Castle and Back was longer and more perceptive, and I wish he told us whether or not the title referred to Kafka's Schloss. I guess I'll have to find out for myself. But I'm so pleased by the good articles here that I won't dwell on that, and I won't dwell on William Saletan's review of The Stuff of Thought by brain philosopher Steven Pinker except to point out that for the second time in two weeks, the NYTBR has recruited a journalist from the online magazine Slate to write about a subject that's too deep for his swimming class. Last week Slate's Bible specialist David Plotz revealed that he had never heard of the field known as biblical scholarship, and this week William Saletan reveals his ignorance of Philosophy 101:

"The Stuff of Thought" explores the duality of human cognition: the modesty of its construction and the majesty of its constructive power. Pinker weaves this paradox from a series of opposing theories. Philosophical realists, for instance, think perception comes from reality. Idealists think it's all in our heads. Pinker says it comes from reality but is organized and reorganized by the mind.

Actually it was Immanuel Kant who said that. He died a long time ago. Pinker's book attempts to go much further than this, but there's no evidence that Saletan is capable of following along. It's nice that the Book Review is trying to include online writers, but they might want to look further than Slate.com in the future.

Ed Champion hates Toni Bentley's review of Katha Pollitt's Learning To Drive, but I'm full up from all the fiction reviews and don't even feel like figuring out what the fuss is about. I did read the earnest but unsurprisingly dismissive Leslie Gelb article about John J. Mearsheimer and Stephen M. Walt's controversial The Israel Lobby and U. S. Foreign Policy as well as David Margolick's inquisitive cover article on Jeffrey Toobin's The Nine: Inside the Secret World of the Supreme Court but it's the Day of Atonement and I shouldn't even be online right now (much less eating breakfast, which I'm also doing) so I'm going to cut my coverage here.

If the New York Times Book Review were always this substantial, I'd have to find something else in the world to complain about every weekend.



This blog post is part of the series Reviewing the New York Times Book Review. The next post in the series is Reviewing the Review: September 30 2007. The previous post in the series is Reviewing the Review: September 16 2007.


Bookmark and Share

3 reponses to "Reviewing the Review: September 23 2007"

by drplacebo on Saturday, September 22, 2007 02:22 pm

Once againan insightful look at the NYTBR.Getting back to the hardcover-softcover issue: It strikes me that the hardcover release is like what the film industry used to do years ago. They would release a new film in the big downtown theatres, and then dole them out to the "neighborhoods" after a couple of weeks. It was sort of an elitist thing. In my native Chicago, a big film like say "Goldfinger" would come out and play only in the Loop. Then, when the crowds died down, it would appear in our neighborhood cinemas. The film industry has long since abandoned this approach. Now a major film appears in all cinemas (softcover if you will) at once.

by Billectric on Monday, September 24, 2007 09:01 am

Testament of DrMabuseEd "DrMabuse" Champion is simply saying that criticism should offer specific examples, not nebulous dismissive wisecracks. I agree.

by sceter1138 on Tuesday, September 25, 2007 08:53 am

Not A PhilosopherOh please don't refer to Stephen Pinker as a philosopher. It's like calling Norman Mailer an expert.

EXPLORE RELATED ARTICLES
End of an Experiment: Releasing the Review
Reviewing the Review: May 9 2010
Reviewing the Review: February 14 2010
Reviewing the Health Care Reform Debate

Action Poetry

Nine years old and running, Action Poetry is an open forum for sharing original poems.

That Guy In The Corner Room by nerdgirl
Haiku on War by tortilla
On Quitting the Internet for 7 Weeks by poetpunk

Litkicks Says "Occupy!"

• When Wall Street Occupied Me
• Occupy Wall Street: How the People's Mic Works
• Occupy Wall Street: In Search of Honest Capitalism
• Adbusters: The Zine That Created the Occupy Movement
• How a Protest Survives
• Why the Tea Party and Occupy Should Protest Together

and ...

• Occupy Your Mind: A Litkicks Digital Library

Search

On This Date

... in 2006
Dark Day for Curious George by Caryn Thurman

... in 2006
A Little Bit of Pixie Dust… by Caryn Thurman

... in 2008
Jamelah Reads the Classics: Ulysses, Part 2 by Jamelah Earle

... in 2009
Reviewing the Review: February 8 2009 by Levi Asher

... in 2010
Just Kids by Patti Smith by Levi Asher

Twitter

Follow Levi Asher on Twitter: @asheresque

By Author

FEATURED ARTICLES BY ALAN BISBORT
• Beatniks: How I Wrote A Subculture Guidebook
• Baseball: The Great American Literary Sport
• Written In Prison
All Articles By Alan Bisbort

FEATURED ARTICLES BY LEVI ASHER
• The Beat Generation
• In Gatsby's Tracks: Locating the Valley of Ashes in a 1924 Photo
• FINDING THE INTERNET
All Articles By Levi Asher

FEATURED ARTICLES BY BILL ECTRIC
• Samuel Taylor Coleridge
• The Mary Shelley Story
• Metafiction and the 4th Wall
All Articles By Bill Ectric

FEATURED ARTICLES BY GARRETT KENYON
• The Top Ten Crime and Mystery Novels of 2009
• The Big Dime: Ten Best Crime Novels of the Past Year
• Advancing the Darkness: Five Modern Masters of Mystery and Crime
All Articles By Garrett Kenyon

FEATURED ARTICLES BY MICHAEL NORRIS
• Francoise Sagan: Sex, Drugs and Literature
• Marcel Proust: Beyond the Madeleines
• Capitaine Achab
All Articles By Michael Norris

FEATURED ARTICLES BY CLAUDIA MOSCOVICI
• The Conformism of Postmodern Style
• Fiction and Cultural Memory: Writing From Ceausescu's Romania
• An Unlikely Cocktail: Mixing Pop and Bourbon in the Palace of Versailles
All Articles By Claudia Moscovici

FEATURED ARTICLES BY JAMELAH EARLE
• For Sale: Baby Shoes, Never Worn.
• Jonathan Swift and Lady Montagu: an 18th Century Literary Smackdown
• Villanelles, Sonnets and Meter
All Articles By Jamelah Earle

FEATURED ARTICLES BY DEDI FELMAN
• Enter Sandman: Neil Gaiman at PEN World Voices
• Adaptations: A PEN World Voices 2010 Conversation About Literature and Film
• Herta Who?
All Articles By Dedi Felman

ALL AUTHORS

Original Books from Literary Kicks!

"Poker is a writer's game, and writing is a poker game ..."

SEE ALL LITKICKS PUBLICATIONS

Featured Articles

Mark Vonnegut in Tribeca

Reading Infinite Jest

W. B. Yeats: A Fool Amongst Wolves

Instant Poetry With Paul Muldoon And Brad Leithauser

Popular Articles

MOST READ THIS YEAR

• Philosophy Weekend: Why Ayn Rand Is Wrong (and Why It Matters)
• Occupy Wall Street: How the People's Mic Works
• Announcing ... Literary Kicks Books for Kindle
• Philosophy Weekend: Nicholson Baker's Case for Pacifism

MOST COMMENTED THIS MONTH

• Philosophy Weekend: Does Ultimate Evil Exist?
• Philosophy Weekend: What is Wealth, and Why Shouldn't We Talk About It?
• Philosophy Weekend: Why Ayn Rand Is Still Wrong
• Kerouac Goes To Cannes, and Other Beat News

Feed

RSS

 

Literary Kicks • About Us