One of the best things critics can do is complete the thoughts we struggle to formulate ourselves when we read new books. I balked at buying James Wood's literary study How Fiction Works
recently after reading several pages in a bookstore, sensing that I might find the air too rarefied. After reading Walter Kirn's consideration of the book on the cover of this week's New York Times Book Review
, I feel better about this tough decision.
Kirn appears to be both impressed and offended by Wood's unimpeachable knowledge and authority, not to mention his increasing fame and "Anton Ego"-like (*
) critical aura. Kirn mocks Wood gently at first, then more openly later:
... he flashes the Burberry lining of his jacket whenever he rises from his armchair to fetch another Harvard Classic.
By the article's last line, Kirn finally dismisses Wood's book completely:
there is one thing this volume answers dismissively: Why Readers Nap
Despite the jabs, this is a respectful review of what is clearly an important book, and that's why I think the NYTBR made a good choice in asking the skeptical Walter Kirn to take it on.
The Wood review provides this NYTBR's biggest splash. Bill Keller, a NY Times big-shot who resembles Donald Rumsfeld
worries me when he paraphrases Garibaldi in the very first paragraph of his review of John Carlin's Playing the Enemy: Nelson Mandela and the Game That Made a Nation
. Fortunately, though, Keller turns out to have a good political story to tell (as a former Johannesburg bureau chief for the Times, he must know South African sports from all the angles). He makes a strong case for the relevance of this book, which I think I'll be checking out.
Beyond those two pieces, I can only report the typical ennui of several more notices of new books that feel hard to tell apart. Sophie Gee says "the bloggers" have been enthusiastic about The Gargoyle
by Andrew Davidson. Not any bloggers I've read lately
, but okay. Stacey D'Erasmo does some good work with a "Tempest" theme in reviewing A Blessed Child
by cinematic daughter Linn Ullmann, but I still know I'll never get around to reading this book. Liesl Schillinger doesn't really breathe life into a novel about hip young American expatriates in Germany, This Must Be the Place
by Anna Winger, and I wish Schillinger had pointed out something I've said a few times before: if you can't come up with a better title for your novel than a Talking Heads or Elvis Costello
song, you really shouldn't get to publish a novel at all. (Although I guess we'll give Carol Alt
a free pass).