Literary Kicks

Opinions, Observations and Research


Favorite Series

Levi Asher's Memoir of the Internet Industry, 1993-2003

Marcel Proust: Beyond The Madeleines

The Great Book Pricing Debate of 2007

Overrated Writers of 2006

FEATURED ARTICLES FROM 2010
• The Top Ten Crime and Mystery Novels of 2009
• In Gatsby's Tracks: Locating the Valley of Ashes in a 1924 Photo
• A Murder and a Metaphor: Litkicks Mystery Spot #1
All Articles From 2010

FEATURED ARTICLES FROM 2009
• FINDING THE INTERNET
• Enter Sandman: Neil Gaiman at PEN World Voices
• A Memoir In Progress
All Articles From 2009

FEATURED ARTICLES FROM 2008
• Francoise Sagan: Sex, Drugs and Literature
• Capitaine Achab
• Les Soixante-Huitards
All Articles From 2008

FEATURED ARTICLES FROM 2007
• Jonathan Swift and Lady Montagu: an 18th Century Literary Smackdown
• DOES LITERARY FICTION SUFFER FROM DYSFUNCTIONAL PRICING? A Conversation
• Cormac McCarthy: Owning My Hate
All Articles From 2007

FEATURED ARTICLES FROM 2006
• For Sale: Baby Shoes, Never Worn.
• The Overrated Writers of 2006
• Overrated Writers, Part One: Philip Roth
All Articles From 2006

FEATURED ARTICLES FROM 2005
• Favorite Poem: The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock
• Samuel Taylor Coleridge
• About Us
All Articles From 2005

FEATURED ARTICLES FROM 2004
• When Corso Dropped his BOMB
• Rod Serling
• Danger on Peaks: Gary Snyder’s Latest
All Articles From 2004

FEATURED ARTICLES FROM 2003
• Jim Morrison: A ‘Serious’ Poet?
• Villanelles, Sonnets and Meter
• E. E. Cummings
All Articles From 2003

FEATURED ARTICLES FROM 2002
• Dorothy Parker
• James Joyce
• On Western Haiku
All Articles From 2002

FEATURED ARTICLES FROM 2001
• Hunter S. Thompson
• Summer Of Love: Hippie Writers & Latter-Day Beats
• J. D. Salinger
All Articles From 2001

FEATURED ARTICLES FROM 2000
• Beat News: April 14 2000
• Beat News: June 16 2000
• Beat News: December 14 2000
All Articles From 2000

FEATURED ARTICLES FROM 1999
• Beat News: April 4 1999
• Beat News: June 20 1999
• LitKicks Summer Poetry Happening at the Bitter End
All Articles From 1999

FEATURED ARTICLES FROM 1998
• Ed Sanders
• Beat News: November 4 1998
• Jack Micheline
All Articles From 1998

FEATURED ARTICLES FROM 1997
• Sliced Bardo: A William S. Burroughs Memorial
• Tales of Beatnik Glory
• How I Met Ginsberg
All Articles From 1997

FEATURED ARTICLES FROM 1996
• Arthur Rimbaud
• Jane Bowles
• d. a. levy
All Articles From 1996

FEATURED ARTICLES FROM 1995
• Charles Bukowski
• Paul Bowles
• My Audition for On The Road
All Articles From 1995

FEATURED ARTICLES FROM 1994
• The Beat Generation
• Jack Kerouac
• Allen Ginsberg
All Articles From 1994

About LitKicks

Literary Kicks was born on July 23, 1994. Here's a page about who we are and where we've been.

Africa
African-American
American
Arabic
Audio Literature
Awards
Beat Generation
Being A Writer
Big Thinking
Biography
Bookselling
Breakfast Club
British
Classics
Comedy
Comix
Drama
Eastern
Eastern European
Ecology
Economics
Events
Existential
Fantasy
Fiction
Film
French
Haiku
Harlem Renaissance
Hiphop
History
Indie
Internet Culture
Interviews
Jazz Age
Jewish
Kid Lit
La Boheme
Language
Latin
Lists
Lit-Crit
LitKicks
Love
Memes
Modernism
Music
Mystery
National Poetry Month
Nature
New York City
News
Overrated Writers
Personal
Places
Poetry
Poetry Readings
Poker
Politics
Polls and Questions
Postmodernism
Psychology
Publishing
Reading
Religion
Reviews
Romantic
Russian
Science Fiction
Southern
Spoken Word
Sports
Summer Of Love
Technology
Television
The Memoir
Transcendentalism
Transgressive
Tributes
Uncategorized
Victorian
Visual Art
What Are You Reading
Women

Reviewing the Review: January 30 2010

by Levi Asher on Sunday, January 31, 2010 08:54 am
Africa, Fiction, Music, New York City, Religion

This isn't widely remembered today, but for about fifteen years Patti Smith was nearly as reclusive as J. D. Salinger. First she helped invent punk rock and released four superb albums in the 1970s, then she disappeared to marry fellow musician Fred "Sonic" Smith and live quietly as a mother and wife on the shores of Lake St. Clair in Michigan. She magically reappeared and resumed her transformative performance art in the mid-90s after her husband's sudden death, and now can be spotted happily walking around the vicinity of McDougal Street and Bleecker Street in Greenwich Village, as natural as if she'd never left.

All of which is to say that there are many reasons why it would have been hard to believe several years ago that a memoir by Patti Smith would ever appear on the cover of the New York Times Book Review. One reason is that it's still hard to believe that Patti would ever write a memoir; another is is that, until fairly recently, the New York Times Book Review was rather too stodgy to have put her on the cover if she had. And when did the NYTBR stop being so stodgy? I've met editor Sam Tanenhaus, who has built his career upon "stodgy". This cannot have been his idea, so one of his deputies must get the credit.

Patti's memoir is called Just Kids and it's about her early years in the Warholesque New York City/St. Marks Place scene with her BFF Robert Mapplethorpe. Of course I'll read the book, and I don't really need to consult Tom Carson's mostly positive review to know there's a 99% chance I'll love it. Maybe someday she'll write about her 15 year seclusion and her return to live performance as well.

Candy Slice naturally eclipses the rest of this weekend's publication on first glance, though there's much else good here. Young novelist Wells Tower appraises his elder T. Coraghessan Boyle's Wild Child: Stories and delivers a carefully reasoned verdict: Boyle pulls off the title story (about the Wild Boy of Aveyron) but is elsewhere too haphazard, too careless with his ambitious plots. I'm impressed by Tower's analysis, though it's strange that he spends a full page describing Boyle's handling of the Wild Boy of Aveyron story without mentioning that Francois Truffaut made a great movie about the same subject, also titled Wild Child in English. Was Boyle's story inspired by Truffaut's film? Does Tower even know that this film exists? I'm sure I'm not the only reader stopped short by this question.

Liesl Schillinger frames Rebecca Newberger Goldstein's 36 Arguments for the Existence of God attractively, and I'm glad to learn that this book is a novel. I had seen its title but understood it literally; I'm glad it's a fictional treatment, because I already sat through Philosophy 101. Kaiama L. Glover introduces us to the main topics covered in Chinua Achebe's essay collection The Education of a British-Protected Child, and Amy Bloom steps us through some familiar but still important questions about the nature and sustainability of happiness in an endpaper that sweeps through a few recent books promising to help us attain it.

I'm sure a memoir by Patti Smith will bring more happiness than any self-help book, and on the Patti account I have only one slight complaint: several mentions in this Book Review might lead a Patti neophyte to think that her fame is based on her 1978 hit single "Because the Night". That song was a chart success, but I have one word to say to anybody who wants to know what the fuss was really about. Horses.




This blog post is part of the series Reviewing the New York Times Book Review. The next post in the series is Reviewing the Review: February 7 2010. The previous post in the series is Reviewing the Review: January 24 2010.


Bookmark and Share

6 reponses to "Reviewing the Review: January 30 2010"

by Dan on Sunday, January 31, 2010 11:46 am

Don't you mean, 'the fuss was about really about HORSE?' (heroin?)

  • reply
by Richard Grayson on Sunday, January 31, 2010 01:15 pm

"Horses," of course

But I wish I still had the autographed chapbook of poems I got one day in the Gotham Book Mart. That's when I first discovered her.

  • reply
by Levi Asher on Sunday, January 31, 2010 02:44 pm

Dan, I don't think I've ever heard that Patti used heroin ... doesn't sound like her style to me.

  • reply
by Edward Champion on Monday, February 1, 2010 01:42 am

I wouldn't call Tower's analysis of Boyle's latest collection "well reasoned." The novella, yes; but not the other stories. I've actually read the collection and Tower's assessment of "Question 62" as "daytime TV drama" misses the point that the dialogue is written in a deliberately monotonous way, to demonstrate the clinical discussion that even an extraordinary political measure can generate during the canvassing process. Deliberately weary, in other words. Like much of politics. (But I will agree with him on "Thirteen Hundred Rats," which is a tad contrived.) Tower doesn't convey the sheer pleasure that Boyle is having with his short stories, shared by the reader -- presumably because the NYTBR editors are terrified of conveying that even "literary" authors don't necessarily have to be read like prescriptive castor oil.

  • reply
by asheresque on Monday, February 1, 2010 08:36 am

Thanks for feedback, Ed -- I know you respect Boyle's work a lot. In this case, I actually read one of the short stories in this book, the one about the petsitter and the dog who gets cloned, because it was chosen for a Best American Short Stories volume. In this case my experience was exactly what Wells Tower described -- I was intrigued by the setup, then disappointed when the story went nowhere. That's why I agreed with Tower's mixed feelings in this case.

  • reply
by Michael_Norris on Monday, February 1, 2010 10:09 am

Levi, I think that a memoir of Patti's time with the legendary Fred Smith of the MC5 would be awesome. I read somewhere that when Smith died, Patti was struggling financially, and had to work hard to re-kindle her career. I plan to follow her Rimbaud pilgramage one day.....

  • reply

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
EXPLORE RELATED ARTICLES
In Gatsby's Tracks: Locating the Valley of Ashes in a 1924 Photo
Jack Kerouac
The Overrated Writers of 2006
Jonathan Swift and Lady Montagu: an 18th Century Literary Smackdown

Action Poetry

Nine years old and running, Action Poetry is an open forum for sharing original poems.

haiku bouncer by mickeyz
Election Day Blues (Love Letter to the Occupy Movement) by Lawrence Parlier
A Brief Diary of a Social Media Troll by hkyuen

Litkicks Says "Occupy!"

• When Wall Street Occupied Me
• Occupy Wall Street: How the People's Mic Works
• Occupy Wall Street: In Search of Honest Capitalism
• Adbusters: The Zine That Created the Occupy Movement
• How a Protest Survives
• Why the Tea Party and Occupy Should Protest Together

and ...

• Occupy Your Mind: A Litkicks Digital Library

Search

On This Date

... in 1998
Beat News: February 2 1998 by Levi Asher

... in 2006
Malamud Is The Case by Levi Asher

... in 2007
Reviewing the Review: February 4 2007 by Levi Asher

... in 2009
LOST IN THE SUPERMARKET by Levi Asher

... in 2010
Invisible by Paul Auster by Meg Wise_Lawrence

Twitter

Follow Levi Asher on Twitter: @asheresque

By Author

FEATURED ARTICLES BY DEDI FELMAN
• Enter Sandman: Neil Gaiman at PEN World Voices
• Adaptations: A PEN World Voices 2010 Conversation About Literature and Film
• Herta Who?
All Articles By Dedi Felman

FEATURED ARTICLES BY CLAUDIA MOSCOVICI
• The Conformism of Postmodern Style
• Fiction and Cultural Memory: Writing From Ceausescu's Romania
• An Unlikely Cocktail: Mixing Pop and Bourbon in the Palace of Versailles
All Articles By Claudia Moscovici

FEATURED ARTICLES BY GARRETT KENYON
• The Top Ten Crime and Mystery Novels of 2009
• The Big Dime: Ten Best Crime Novels of the Past Year
• Advancing the Darkness: Five Modern Masters of Mystery and Crime
All Articles By Garrett Kenyon

FEATURED ARTICLES BY LEVI ASHER
• The Beat Generation
• In Gatsby's Tracks: Locating the Valley of Ashes in a 1924 Photo
• FINDING THE INTERNET
All Articles By Levi Asher

FEATURED ARTICLES BY JAMELAH EARLE
• For Sale: Baby Shoes, Never Worn.
• Jonathan Swift and Lady Montagu: an 18th Century Literary Smackdown
• Villanelles, Sonnets and Meter
All Articles By Jamelah Earle

FEATURED ARTICLES BY BILL ECTRIC
• Samuel Taylor Coleridge
• The Mary Shelley Story
• Metafiction and the 4th Wall
All Articles By Bill Ectric

FEATURED ARTICLES BY ALAN BISBORT
• Beatniks: How I Wrote A Subculture Guidebook
• Baseball: The Great American Literary Sport
• Written In Prison
All Articles By Alan Bisbort

FEATURED ARTICLES BY MICHAEL NORRIS
• Francoise Sagan: Sex, Drugs and Literature
• Marcel Proust: Beyond the Madeleines
• Capitaine Achab
All Articles By Michael Norris

ALL AUTHORS

Original Books from Literary Kicks!

Chiaroscuro: Assorted Literary Essays

SEE ALL LITKICKS PUBLICATIONS

Featured Articles

John Banville, the 20 Minute Guitar Solo and Truth in Fiction

Metafiction and the 4th Wall

The Reading Room

William James and the Theory of Emotion

Popular Articles

MOST READ THIS YEAR

• Philosophy Weekend: Why Ayn Rand Is Wrong (and Why It Matters)
• Occupy Wall Street: How the People's Mic Works
• Announcing ... Literary Kicks Books for Kindle
• Philosophy Weekend: Taking Down Ayn Rand

MOST COMMENTED THIS MONTH

• Philosophy Weekend: Does Ultimate Evil Exist?
• Philosophy Weekend: What is Wealth, and Why Shouldn't We Talk About It?
• Philosophy Weekend: Where This Is Heading
• Kerouac Goes To Cannes, and Other Beat News

Feed

RSS

 

Literary Kicks • About Us