In an effort not to be outdone by 50 Cent and Diddy and the various after parties at the MTV Video Music Awards, the folks at what's ominously known as Reed Business Information have announced the details and nominees for the first
Quill Awards. You may be asking "What the hell is a Quill Award?" -- I know I sure did. Apparently the Quill Award is hyped to be the literary equivalent of the People's Choice Awards -- and like the People's Choice Awards where the nominees are chosen by editors of such fine publications as
Entertainment Weekly, the Quill Awards nominees are selected by bookseller and librarian subscribers to
Publisher's Weekly. (Did I mention that Reed Business Information is the parent company of
Publisher's Weekly?) You can see the nominees in each category
here and yes, my friends, there
is a Bob Dylan nod. Some have said the choices are "interesting" or "bizarre". Frankly I find them predictable, safe and a little boring. Not the works themselves, naturally, but choosing them isn't exactly going out on a limb here. But, it is based on popularity, after all and is touted to be "a consumer driven celebration of the written word" -- hoo boy, indeed. I'm sure I'm being overly critical, but something just didn't set right with me after taking a look at their nominating criteria: